QUARTERLY REPORT - APRIL 2023
Broad outperformance of sustainable investment (SI) strategies in a volatile quarter
- Environmental Opportunities (EO) outperformance and green sector divergence – EO was 6.6% ahead of the market in Q1, reversing much of the 7.9% underperformance in 2022. This performance was driven by Energy Efficiency, up 17.0%, which typically outperforms in a cyclical upturn. The weakest sector was Renewable & Alternative Energy, down -2.2%, despite the announcement of strong government support from the US Inflation Reduction Act and the EU Net Zero Industry Act.
- Underweight Energy moves from headwind to tailwind – The Energy sector underperformed in Q1, as oil prices fell, following strength in 2022. This benefited strategies such as Global Choice and EU PAB, which are both 4.8% underweight Energy.
- Overweight Technology positive – Technology, in which all global and developed SI strategies are overweight, was positive across strategies, although some saw a negative selection effect. The largest positive impact from Technology was in the US.
- Financials, a mixed bag – Positioning in Financials varied across SI strategies. EO was underweight, adding to returns, while ESG Low Carbon was overweight, acting as a headwind. The biggest headwinds from Financials were in EM, APAC and Japan.
- Valuations manageable but creeping up – SI valuations are down vs 2021 highs and below 5-year averages, except PAB. However, absolute P/Es' have risen in the quarter and the premia over market are now above 5-year averages. Price to Book premia are at 5-year averages. FTSE4Good is the only strategy trading below the market, while EM has the lowest average premium, and Japan the highest.
Subscribe to our Market Maps reports here.
To support your investment decision-making, we produce specialist content that provides analysis and insights on a range of investment topics. Go to our hub for valuable Market Insights.